The Day I Saw a 2007 Out-of-Print Item Selling as Grade A, Beyond the Display Case Glass
It was the first scene I witnessed in front of a second-hand shop display case on the third floor of Nakano Broadway. An Alter 1/8 scale figure released in 2007 was classified as Grade A box condition. Though it was 12 years post-release, there wasn't a single scratch on the box corners, and even the tape marks inside the blister were clean. The price tag bore two characters: "未開封·A級" (Unopened · Grade A). At the time in Korea, the same product was selling with a crushed box under the vague description "used, good condition."
A question arose that day. Why do Japanese second-hand figures circulate like new even after 10 years? By what standards are those two characters on the grade label determined? What should people hunting for out-of-print scales look for in front of second-hand shop display cases? To cut to the conclusion: Japan's second-hand figure market is an ecosystem where grading systems, storage culture, and inventory turnover interlock and turn together. Understanding this ecosystem's grammar makes hunting out-of-print items possible even through direct purchases from Korea.
How Do You Read Second-Hand Grade Labels?
Japanese second-hand shops' grading systems generally divide into 4-5 levels from S-grade (unopened new) to C-grade (noticeable damage), where A-grade means "opened but with almost no display traces," and B-grade means "shows usage but no missing parts." Each grade is the result of separately evaluating box, blister, body, and parts, and some shops even subdivide the same A-grade to specify "箱A/本体B" (Box A / Body B) when only the box is A but the body is B.
Two things are key to reading grade labels. First, grades vary subtly between shops. Some second-hand shops downgrade to B-grade for even a 1mm dent on a box corner, while others classify it as A-grade. After 2020, it became conventional wisdom in Korean direct-purchase communities that "A-grade from certain Japanese mail-order sites is equivalent to S-grade from other companies." Indeed, among A-grade used items I've received, there were unopened, undisplayed items with the blister tape not even removed.
Second, grades do not guarantee the absence of missing parts. Even A-grade items may lack bonus postcards or base stands, with phrases like "台座欠品" (base missing) hidden in the notes section at the bottom of the product page. It's a trap easy to miss if you can't read Japanese. Before direct purchase, you must check the notes section even if it means running it through Google Translate. I once failed to receive a Nendoroid bonus face part due to this mistake.
Why Japanese Second-Hand Items Are in Good Condition: Differences in Storage Culture
Japanese collectors view boxes as assets. In Korea, the reaction "Why does the box matter if I'm going to put it in a glass case anyway?" is common, but in Japan, box condition directly affects resale value. A Japanese collector I met on the return trip from Wonder Festival in 2015 said, "The box is the figure's resume." One piece of blister tape, one crease mark on the instructions—these separate grades.
This culture stems from physical storage environments. Japanese apartments have good humidity control, and collectors store boxes standing upright rather than stacked flat. The "crushed box on bottom from stacking" frequently seen in Korean communities is rare in Japan. Looking at Japanese second-hand shop display cases, you see boxes standing with corners maintaining 90-degree angles. Tape without a trace of adhesive residue, box fronts that haven't faded. These are 10-year-old products.
Another factor is the difference in display periods. Among Japanese collectors, many open figures but don't display them. There's a culture of "開封確認のみ" (opening for confirmation only)—opening to check condition, then immediately repackaging. Though difficult to understand from a Korean perspective, thanks to this, the second-hand market sees figures that are "opened but haven't collected a speck of dust." This is why A-grade used items look like new.
1/7 Scale figure Re:Zero - Starting Life in Another World- Rem Cream Soda →The Beginning of Out-of-Print Hunting: The Weapon Called Inventory Turnover
Japanese second-hand shops turn inventory quickly. In Korea, out-of-print figures are "something to wait for until they appear," but in Japan, new stock arrives weekly. In a 2019 interview, one Japanese second-hand shop representative stated, "Popular out-of-print scales arrive at an average of 3-5 per month." This is thanks to the circulation structure where collectors sell figures, buy again, and sell again.
This turnover rate directly connects to search timing. Korean direct-purchase communities share the tip to "check Japanese mail-order sites' used pages at 1 AM daily." This is because new stock gets registered around midnight Japan time. Using this method in 2021, I snagged a Good Smile 1/8 scale out of print since 2013 in A-grade. The price was 1.3 times the original retail price—half the Korean premium market rate.
High inventory turnover also means "if you miss it, it'll come again." When you first see an out-of-print figure, you panic and feel you must buy immediately, but in reality, the same product often reappears within 2-3 months. Of course, grade and price may differ. What's needed then is a sense of appropriate pricing by grade. If you miss an A-grade at 30,000 yen, don't buy a B-grade at 30,000 yen. Patient endurance is the basic skill of out-of-print hunting.
Details Beyond Grade: Reading Actual Condition Through Photos
Photos on second-hand shop product pages are more honest than grade labels. Most Japanese second-hand shops upload individual shots of all six box sides, blister, body front/side/rear, base, and parts. Cases exceeding 15 photos are common. Three places to look:
First, box corners. Even A-grade items sometimes have slightly pressed corners. Zoom in on photos to check for white compression marks. Second, blister tape marks. This reveals whether it's been repackaged. Removing and reapplying tape causes dust to settle on the adhesive surface or edges to lift. If the tape in photos is cleanly adhered, it's either unopened or repackaged immediately after opening.
Third, the tips of the body's hair parts. Dust settles first on hair tips and inside skirt pleats. If hair tips look hazy when you zoom in on photos, it signals a long display period. Even if it's A-grade, I reconsider purchase if this area is unclear. Conversely, if it's B-grade but hair tips are clean, it's a good value choice. Grades are based on boxes, but body condition can only be confirmed through photos.
FuRyu / scale figure Ina Awa →Different Sourcing Routes for Each Second-Hand Shop: Where Does What Come Out Well?
Japanese second-hand shops divide broadly into three types: nationwide chain second-hand shops, holy land-based shops in Akihabara/Nakano, and mail-order specialty second-hand shops. Each has different sourcing routes, and accordingly, the items that come out well differ.
Nationwide chain second-hand shops have many items from regional collectors. They have high turnover of mainstream products like prize figures and Nendoroids, but rare scales are uncommon. Instead, prices are cheap. A 2012 Nendoroid I saw at an Osaka branch in 2018 was box B-grade at 2,000 yen—one-third of the Korean used market rate.
Holy land-based shops specialize in high-end scales and limited editions. Rare items like completed garage kits from Wonder Festival After events or event-limited color versions occasionally arrive. Prices are expensive but condition is certain. A 2010 Wonder Festival limited resin kit I saw at one second-hand shop on Nakano Broadway's fourth floor was perfect S-grade with box, instructions, and artist signature card. Price: 80,000 yen. While I hesitated, it disappeared the next day.
Mail-order specialty second-hand shops have overwhelming inventory. The same product often appears in multiple grades, allowing comparison purchasing. The disadvantage is not being able to see the actual item. Products on the borderline between A-grade and B-grade are difficult to judge from photos alone. I've bought B-grade through mail order and been pleased it was better than expected, and conversely, been flustered when A-grade arrived with broken styrofoam inside the box.
The Option Called No Box (箱無し): When Is It Worth Considering?
Japanese second-hand shops have a separate "箱無し" (no box) category. These are body-only products, priced at about half that of boxed products. Some Korean collectors view "no box as not used but trash," but approaching it practically, it's a reasonable choice.
Two cases when no box is worth considering. First, when acquiring long out-of-print scales cheaply for display purposes. If you have no resale plans and will only put it in a glass case, the box is baggage. I once purchased an Alter 1/7 scale out of print since 2017 without box for 12,000 yen. The boxed market rate was 25,000 yen. The body condition was A-grade level, and it still stands well in my glass case.
Second, when using it as a source for parts replacement or customization. Among no-box products are incomplete items missing only specific parts—only the head part with no body, or only the base with no body. Garage kit makers and repaint workers use such parts as sources. Prices are one-tenth of complete products. Of course, they're useless to general collectors, but if you have a clear purpose, they're treasure.
When buying no-box products, the caution is confirming parts composition. You must carefully read whether the product page has notations like "本体のみ" (body only) or "台座欠品" (base missing). You must purchase on the premise that what's photographed is everything, and there's almost no way to separately obtain missing parts.
Spiritale 1/6 Scale Figure Atelier Ryza 2: Lost Legends and the Secret Fairy Ryza White Swimsuit Ver. →Hunting Out-of-Print Items Through Direct Purchase: Shipping, Customs, Risk Management
There are broadly two methods for bringing Japanese second-hand figures to Korea: direct purchase using package forwarding, or using Korean proxy services. Each has pros and cons, but since speed is life in out-of-print hunting, I recommend direct purchase.
The key to the package forwarding route is calculating shipping costs. Many Japanese mail-order sites don't ship directly overseas, so you must receive at a Japanese domestic address (forwarding service) then re-ship to Korea. Forwarding fees are weight-based, and one scale figure is generally 1-2kg. As of 2023, forwarding fees were in the 1,500-2,000 yen per kg range. Add 3,000 yen including box packing materials. You must include this amount in calculations upfront to avoid the regret of "received it more expensively than expected."
Customs are in principle duty-free under USD 150, 13% charged if exceeded, but in reality it's luck. Even for products at the same price level, some don't get charged customs and some do. To be safe, either match purchase amount to under 150 dollars, or include the 13% customs in your budget from the start. I choose the latter. Agonizing to match 150 dollars in front of an out-of-print figure is wasted time.
The risk is damage. During forwarding repackaging, boxes can get pressed or bodies can shake. Cases exist where shops sent A-grade but it arrives as B-grade due to poor forwarding packaging. To reduce this risk, forwarding service selection is important. Use services known in communities as "good at packing figures." If you skimp a few hundred yen and the box gets crushed, you can't even recover your principal.
Shadows of the Second-Hand Market: Repaints, Counterfeits, Grade Disputes
The Japanese second-hand market isn't perfect either. First, repainted products. Products with original paint removed and repainted, occasionally uploaded without "repaint" notation on the product page. If coloring in photos is too vivid or color tone differs from the original, be suspicious. Repainting itself isn't bad, but it's problematic when sold without disclosure.
Second, unlicensed counterfeits. Japanese second-hand shops filter counterfeits, but some slip through. Especially Chinese resin copies that precisely duplicate even boxes are difficult to distinguish with the naked eye. The warning signal is price. If rare out-of-print scales appear below retail price, suspect first. Don't let your guard down even if the shop's reputation is good. In 2020, a Korean community shared a case where a product purchased from a famous Japanese second-hand shop was determined to be counterfeit.
Third, grade inflation. Some second-hand shops list B-grade products as A-grade. Especially mail-order specialty shops where actual inspection is impossible, "This is A-grade?" reactions come only after arrival. What's needed then is checking return policies. Most Japanese second-hand shops accept returns "within 7 days of arrival, unopened condition only." If opened, no returns. Via Korean forwarding, round-trip shipping alone exceeds 10,000 yen, so if it's ambiguous, just using it is reality.
FAQ
Is the actual difference between Japanese second-hand figure grades A and B significant?
Body condition is often similar, but box condition separates grades. A-grade has box corners and blister tape at nearly new levels, while B-grade has noticeable usage signs (corner compression, tape marks, instruction creases). If you have resale plans, choose A-grade; if only for display, B-grade is also a reasonable choice. Price difference averages 20-30%.
When do out-of-print figures appear as second-hand items?
Japanese second-hand shops receive new stock daily, with popular out-of-print scales registered 3-5 times monthly. Checking mail-order sites' used pages around midnight Japan time (1 AM Korea time) lets you see new stock first. Even if your desired product doesn't show, enduring 2-3 months makes reappearance highly likely.
Is it okay to buy second-hand figures without boxes?
If you have no resale plans and only display purposes, it's a reasonable choice. Prices are about half of boxed products, and if body condition is good, value is excellent. However, you must confirm parts composition (base and bonus inclusion) on the product page. There's almost no way to separately obtain missing parts.
What's the possibility that a figure bought from a Japanese second-hand shop is counterfeit?
Though counterfeits occasionally slip through even famous second-hand shops, probability is low. The warning signal is price. Be careful if rare out-of-print items appear below retail price, or if paint texture in photos differs from the original. After arrival, checking box logo print quality, body parting line (parts boundary) treatment, and paint gradation can distinguish most cases.
---
Japan's second-hand figure market is an ecosystem of trust created by transparent grading systems and conscientious storage culture. But that trust ultimately operates on top of buyer judgment. Don't blindly trust grade labels—zoom in on photos, and read Japanese notes sections even if through translation. Out-of-print figures eventually return to those who know how to wait. I hope good connections reach your glass cases today as well.
